I have 2 ETF’s that I have in my IRA account. They are the WisdomTree Dividend Top 100 Fund and the VanGuard Small-Cap Growth Index Fund. I invested the same amount of money into both of these ETF’s in July of 2007. So as the year of 2008 approaches and it’s December now, I thought I would see which one was making the most money for me in these first few months. I do have different thoughts on both funds and what I expected from each one of them. I figured my WisdomTree ETF would be my steady gainer and be a safer bet for growing my assets. The VanGuard ETF is a bigger risk ETF, but the rewards could be a lot bigger, since this ETF focuses on small companies. So I feel like I have a little extra diversification in my IRA account, by having two ETF’s that have different goals.
Now I invested at two different times in these ETF’s, but put the same amount in both on each investment. In July I put $105 into each one of these ETF’s and in August I added an additional $70 in each one. So my total investment into both ETF’s is $175 for each one. I had to pay the broker and transaction fees out of that money, so my total worth is less than $175 for each one of my ETF’s. So as of right now, it seems that my Vanguard Small-Cap is beating out my WisdomTree ETF by $4.14.
DTN (WisdomTree ETF) 2.849 shares = $160.70
VBK (Vanguard Small-Cap ETF) 2.2993 shares = $164.84
So you can see I don’t have a lot of money for retirement right now. I do have some other stocks I own in a traditional account, but this is my total investment in my IRA account right now. I plan to increase my investment rates as I get older. I would like to invest more right now, but just can’t afford to at the momment. Hopefully 2008 will be a better year for me than 2007 was!
Now if you’re interested in either one of these ETF’s, I do recommend them. I did my homework and I liked what I saw in both of them. My small-cap fund is ahead of the one I was counting on for steady gains and I think that’s a great sign. Here are some of their top holdings for each ETF and be sure to let me know if you decide to invest any money in either one of these ETF’s.
WisdomTree Div 100 (DTN)
1. Southern Copper Corporation 7.63%
2. AT&T, Inc. 2.31%
3. Verizon Communications Inc. 1.82%
4. Bristol Myers Squibb Company 1.72%
5. Bank of New York Mellon Corporation 1.67%
6. Progress Energy, Inc. 1.52%
7. Southern Company 1.48%
8. Merck & Co., Inc. 1.47%
9. Public Service Enterprise Group 1.44%
10. Reynolds American, Inc. 1.42%
Now I love the top 10 holdings for this WisdomTree ETF. My favorite is the 7+ percent they have invested into the Southern Copper Corporation. My least favorite on the list would be AT&T. I would like to see the fund manager invest more of that money somewhere else, but overall I really like this ETF. This ETF is invested in the financial sector with 28% and the utility sector is 2nd with 19%. (HIGHLY RECOMENDED)
VanGuard Small-Cap (VBK)
1. Manitowoc Company, Inc. .57%
2. Cytyc .56%
3. Denbury Resources, Inc. .55%
4. Stericycle, Inc. .52%
5. ITT Educational Services, Inc. .51%
6. AK Steel Holding Corporation .50%
7. Trimble Navigation Ltd. .48%
8. Frontier Oil Corporation .47%
9. Varian Semiconductor Equipment Associates, Inc. .45%
10. Cypress Semiconductor Corporation
Recognize many of them companies? Don’t worry your not alone, but the philosphy of the ETF and when you see the largest holding only accounts for .57 percent of the fund, you know they are diversified well. They are mainly invested in the healthcare sector at 17 percent and industrial materials and business services make up 14 percent in each one of those sectors. So 45 percent of the ETF deals with small companies in the healthcare, industrial materials, or business services’ sector. My WisdomTree ETF is geared toward the financial sector of the market and the Vanguard Small-Cap ETF only has a 5 percent stake in the financial market. So this was the perfect ETF to off-set my other ETF and I think I will do well with both of these ETF’s over the years to come.